The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has adopted a cautious approach in its assessment of digital currencies’ potential impact on the international monetary system. It highlights the challenges that must be overcome for them to act as a viable alternative to traditional currencies.
International financial, monetary, and credit organizations were primarily formed after World War II to help return international financial, trade, and industrial cycles to their natural course. With their support, these organizations aimed to enable countries to overcome the economic recessions and crises caused by the devastating events of the first half of the 20th century. Each of these organizations focuses on different areas. Among them, it can be said with certainty that the IMF is the most influential international institution. Founded in 1944 amid World War II, the IMF works to strengthen economic stability and development by offering reform programs, monetary cooperation, and financial assistance to member countries. The IMF has always been at the forefront of addressing various economic crises and acts as a regulatory or standard-setting body in accounting, financial, and commercial matters. However, as the IMF primarily focuses on improving conditions on a macroeconomic scale, it avoids direct interference in the individual affairs of its members. Nonetheless, countries must comply with its conditions and recommendations if they request assistance, loans, special drawing rights (SDRs), or any form of cooperation from the IMF. Given the IMF’s mechanisms and role, it can be said that the IMF’s perspective and approach are among the most critical factors shaping the direction and decision-making of governments, markets, and stakeholders regarding any new phenomenon or event in the global economy.
In recent years, with the emergence of digital currencies and blockchain technology, there has been much debate about their potential impact on the global financial system. The IMF has closely monitored developments in this new field and has shared its views and approach toward the crypto industry and assets through reports, speeches, and interviews with responsible individuals. This article examines the IMF’s views on the crypto industry and digital assets, briefly discussing their potential advantages and disadvantages, regulatory challenges, and implications for international monetary and credit systems.
Opportunities and Threats of Cryptocurrencies from the Perspective of the International Monetary Fund
The IMF evaluates the innovative nature of digital currencies and their operational platform, namely blockchain technology and its applications, positively and as progressive, having explicitly or implicitly endorsed it several times. This institution emphasizes that this new field can create change in various aspects of the financial system. The IMF identifies several advantages of cryptocurrencies but highlights five areas as more significant than others:
1.Broad Capacity for Providing Various Financial Services:
Digital currencies can provide access to diverse financial services for large groups of people without access to traditional banking services. This is particularly evident in developing and underdeveloped countries, where financial institutions are either few and limited, the costs of these monetary and accounting processes are high, or there are cumbersome regulations for conducting transactions.
2.High Efficiency and Returns:
Blockchain technology can simplify financial processes and reduce transaction costs, which is fundamental to the philosophy and objective of the founders of these technologies. For example, the unparalleled efficiency of digital currencies is most impactful when it enables transactions between individuals in a short time and at usually low costs, even when they are located in various parts of the world (so-called cross-border transactions).
3.Facilitation of Innovations:
One of the common supportive and reformative programs for global economic and social development is the backing and financial and moral support for innovations and startups by institutions like the United Nations, the World Bank, and the IMF. The potential of cryptocurrencies allows for easier institutional support and public assistance for such projects and programs.
4.Decentralization:
One of the most significant challenges of traditional financial systems is centralization and issues related to monopoly and market competition. The decentralized nature of cryptocurrencies can reduce the risk of single points of failure and threats to market stability, enhancing competition in the financial sector.
5.High Privacy and Transparency:
On one hand, blockchain technology can help maintain individuals’ privacy in financial transactions. On the other hand, the structures and algorithms employed are designed so that all users can stay informed about transactions, as all information is fully recorded on the blocks. (It should be noted that this aspect can simultaneously create issues and concerns, which will be addressed further.)
However, the IMF consistently points out the risks that cryptocurrencies pose to the international financial system, trade cycles, and even political orders, voicing its concerns in various ways. The risks emphasized by the IMF primarily fall into five areas:
1.(In)Stability of Financial and Economic Cycles:
The volatility of digital currencies and their high sensitivity to bubbles caused by activities like speculation can lead to financial instability. This threat will become particularly serious when these currencies are widely adopted, and major companies and traditional financial and banking systems fully recognize them for their transactions.
2.Money Laundering and Terrorism Financing:
The anonymity and borderless nature of digital currencies can facilitate illegal activities such as money laundering and terrorism financing, making it very difficult to control and trace these actions.
3.Tax Evasion:
The new financial order in governments worldwide is based on the premise that taxes support state and government expenditures; however, the use of digital currencies can significantly increase tax evasion, as the nature of many of these cryptocurrencies allows users to conceal their income and assets from governments.
4.User and Consumer Rights:
The crypto industry’s lack of regulation and oversight can expose users and traders to various frauds (such as Ponzi schemes, phishing, etc.) and other risks.
5.Environmental Pollution:
The nature of cryptocurrency mining is based on algorithms like Proof of Work, which consume vast amounts of energy, and the ecosystems and blockchain networks also require significant energy and cost to sustain and maintain themselves. Given the complex energy situation in the world, environmental consequences could pose serious risks.
All of the points mentioned above have been raised by independent experts and other organizations; however, it is important to note that the IMF bases its opinions on data from experienced legal and economic experts and has made every effort to ensure that it has no specific biases.
Regulatory and Supervisory Challenges
Considering the opportunities and threats outlined and the rapid growth of this emerging industry, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has realized that the primary bottleneck that must be addressed is the issue of law and regulation. Various legal issues and conflicts among countries, organizations, financial systems, and the cryptocurrency industry make establishing such laws very difficult and challenging. Furthermore, finding suitable supervisory processes and enforcement mechanisms will be very hard and complex even if such laws can be drafted. In general, it can be said that three categories of problematic laws exist, which are briefly explained below:
1.Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Laws:
In addition to each country having its laws in this area, the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) is also active at the international level, and some countries refuse to accept its recommendations and guidelines.
2.Diverse and Contradictory Consumer Protection and Investment Laws in Different Countries and Regions:
The conditions in each country are so different that even countries that have free market agreements with one another constantly face serious legal issues. For instance, in the European Union, consumer rights protection is so important that a company like Apple usually faces heavy fines or corrective actions when marketing its goods and services with its typical approach in North America. Meanwhile, investors and entrepreneurs enjoy the most support and benefits in North America, while antitrust laws are more emphasized, and legal disputes between companies are among the most significant issues.
3.Diverse Tax Laws in Different Countries:
Tax laws can create various conflicts regarding form, content, level of strictness, and interpretability. It should be noted that laws have been shaped over decades of legislation in each country or government due to economic, social, cultural, and even ideological conditions. At the same time, the cryptocurrency industry disregards these borders and diversities. Consequently, achieving cooperation at the international level will involve numerous complexities and difficulties, as laws cannot be changed overnight. On the other hand, a strict legal framework cannot be applied to a decentralized ecosystem without harming or destroying it.
Current Approach of the IMF Regarding Cryptocurrencies
Considering these points, we can now outline the current approach and, perhaps more accurately, the IMF’s expectations and recommendations for the cryptocurrency industry.
1.Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing (AML/CFT):
The IMF calls for implementing anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing regulations for cryptocurrency exchanges and other service providers in this space. It is also essential that the FATF engages in this area and that this ecosystem follows the group’s conditions regarding virtual assets.
2.Enhancing Financial Stability:
The IMF advocates for developing international regulatory standards for cryptocurrencies to enhance financial stability and reduce the likelihood of illegal activities.
3.Encouraging Cooperation:
The IMF encourages cooperation between policymakers, regulators, and the private sector to develop effective cryptocurrency regulatory frameworks.
4.Promoting Transparency:
The IMF calls for greater transparency in the crypto industry to build investor trust while reducing the likelihood of fraud and other forms of exploitation. One of the necessities that the IMF emphasizes is the enhancement and development of reporting standards and the manner of presentation for cryptocurrencies, as this would lead to increased accountability of blockchain projects.
5.Providing Technical Assistance:
This international organization has provided significant technical assistance to member countries to enable them to operate within more effective regulatory frameworks. The IMF is negotiating and closely collaborating with national authorities of various countries to strengthen their capacities for monitoring and regulating the crypto market.
6.Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs):
The IMF has encouraged central banks to issue cryptocurrencies. However, it has asked them to consider their national economic conditions and assess the advantages and potential risks of issuing a CBDC. These types of cryptocurrencies can potentially help manage some of the challenges posed by digital currencies while also increasing the efficiency and stability of the monetary system.
IMF’s Approach Over the Past Years
Since the beginning of the expansion and seriousness of the cryptocurrency industry, the IMF has continuously stated its approach. However, more precisely, from 2016 to the present, this institution has regularly and consistently published various reports and articles. By following these, one can discern how the IMF’s views and approaches have evolved. Below, we briefly review the IMF’s yearly approach, as it provides a good perspective on the transformation in its viewpoints and the turning points in its approach.
2016: The IMF acknowledges the potential impact of cryptocurrencies’ advantages and high capacities in reducing costs and expanding financial services.
2017: The IMF’s official cryptocurrency article describes the risks, challenges, and potential advantages.
2018: The institution confirms that cryptocurrencies represent a new form of asset; however, precise regulations must be established for this industry to mitigate risks.
2019: The IMF provides technical and legal assistance to member countries to establish stronger regulatory frameworks.
2020: The IMF emphasizes the need for greater transparency and establishing a structured mechanism for clarifying matters related to this industry.
2021 to Present: The IMF has called for increased cooperation between policymakers, regulators, and the private sector to develop effective regulatory frameworks for cryptocurrencies.
Implications of the IMF’s Approach on the Cryptocurrency Industry
This organization has clearly articulated cryptocurrencies’ positive and negative implications and challenges, demonstrating how they can replace traditional and common processes. While one of the overarching policies of this institution is to support innovations like cryptocurrencies, it should be noted that the overall approach of the IMF always appears cautious and somewhat conservative. This attitude has specific and clear reasons and seems to be prudent.
The IMF’s approaches toward the crypto industry have significant implications for its future, which is rapidly evolving. On one hand, the IMF’s emphasis on enhancing financial stability and reducing the potential for illegal activities may lead to increased regulatory oversight and a more restricted operational environment for blockchain businesses. This could make attracting investment and developing new products and services for startups in this industry more challenging.
On the other hand, the IMF’s positive view on the potential advantages of cryptocurrencies and its support for new domains may lead to greater acceptance of new forms of digital assets and increased investment in the crypto industry. If financial market regulators can strike an appropriate balance between consumer protection and promoting innovation, the crypto industry can continue to grow and evolve in ways that benefit the global economy.
The Future of Interaction Between the Cryptocurrency Industry and International Financial Systems
The future of this emerging industry depends on many factors; however, in summary, it can be stated that if a balance and cooperation between the world of cryptocurrencies and traditional financial and banking systems are well established, and if public acceptance of cryptocurrencies is achieved, then cryptocurrencies will reach the expected status. Nonetheless, several important challenges and issues must be considered.
One significant challenge is the limited use of digital currencies as a reliable means for business and economic processes. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) points out three reasons why cryptocurrencies have not yet become a common currency for financial exchanges and transactions: 1) significant price volatility of cryptocurrencies over short timeframes, 2) high transaction fees for most cryptocurrencies at lower amounts, and 3) the lack of adoption of cryptocurrencies by businesses and companies (especially large corporations). Furthermore, the IMF believes that the decentralized nature of digital currencies has hindered their acceptance as stable and reliable assets for savings, an expectation that traditional assets like gold and oil easily fulfill.
The IMF also emphasizes the potential role of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) in shaping the future of the international monetary system. The IMF notes that CBDCs can help central banks monitor and control money creation and the monetary base, thereby addressing some of the risks associated with the digital currency world. However, the IMF continues to warn that the widespread adoption of CBDCs could lead to unintended consequences. For instance, banks often face mismatches between their assets and customer deposits. If many customers withdraw from their accounts, these mismatched banks can encounter difficulties and become insolvent. CBDCs could easily exacerbate these mismatches, a situation that has led some blockchain projects (such as the Luna cryptocurrency) to failure. Such conditions would yield nothing but economic crises and instability.
Additionally, the IMF has examined the potential impact of digital currencies on the international monetary system regarding reserve currency status and global reference currency. Based on the organization’s analyses, circumstances could change. Still, it seems unlikely that cryptocurrencies will challenge the role of the US dollar as the reference currency for international transactions in the short term. If central banks and large financial institutions begin to hold significant amounts of cryptocurrencies, this possibility would not be far-fetched; however, it is difficult to predict exactly when such a change might begin.
Conclusion
The IMF’s perspective on the cryptocurrency industry and its assets reflects a distinct and balanced outlook that effectively represents this field’s advantages and transformative potential and blockchain-based technologies. On the other hand, it has successfully identified the risks and potential challenges this sector poses to the international monetary system. This organization is active and leading in providing a coordinated global approach to regulating cryptocurrencies and invites all member countries and financial organizations to cooperate. The IMF also consistently emphasizes the need for regulations to combat money laundering, terrorism financing, consumer protection, and financial stability.
At the same time, the IMF has acted cautiously in assessing the potential consequences of digital currencies for the international monetary system, noting the challenges that must be overcome for them to serve as alternatives to traditional currencies. This organization has also clearly outlined the potential effective role of CBDCs in shaping the future of the monetary system while warning of the possible unintended consequences of their widespread acceptance and use.
Ultimately, the IMF’s views on the cryptocurrency industry and assets provide valuable insights for policymakers, regulators, and all stakeholders in this field as they operate within the complex and rapidly evolving landscape of digital currencies and blockchain technology. As the crypto industry continues to grow and develop, the international community needs to engage in constructive dialogue and collaboration to fully realize the potential benefits of these assets while mitigating the associated risks and challenges. The IMF emphasizes that digital currencies present a significant opportunity for increased access to banking and accounting services in developing and less-developed countries.
Sources:
International Monetary Fund. (n.d.). About the IMF. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from https://www.imf.org/en/About
CoinMarketCap. (2021). Cryptocurrency Market Capitalizations. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from https://coinmarketcap.com/
International Monetary Fund. (2021). Fiscal Monitor: Achieving a Green Recovery. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/FM/Issues/2021/04/06/fiscal-monitor-april-2021
European Central Bank. (2021). Virtual Currency Schemes – a Further Analysis. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from https://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/other/virtualcurrencyschemes202102en.pdf
International Monetary Fund. (2018). Challenges to Monetary Policy in the Twenty-First Century. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/Staff-Discussion-Notes/Issues/2018/06/22/Challenges-to-Monetary-Policy-in-the-Twenty-First-Century-45963
Financial Action Task Force. (2019). Guidance for a Risk-Based Approach to Virtual Assets and Virtual Asset Service Providers. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from https://www.fatf-gafi.org/media/fatf/documents/recommendations/RBA-VA-VASPs.pdf
European Banking Authority. (2019). Report with Advice for the European Commission on Crypto-Assets. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from https://www.eba.europa.eu/sites/default/documents/files/documents/10180/2555547/70f7b2f9-3cf4-4bb8-9f3a-8c9edf5bdfaa/EBA%20Report%20on%20crypto-assets.pdf
International Monetary Fund. (2023). IMF Approach to Central Bank Digital Currency Capacity Development, April 11, 2023, from
https://www.imf.org/-/media/Files/Publications/PP/2023/English/PPEA2023016.ashx
International Monetary Fund. (2021). World Economic Outlook: Managing Divergent Recoveries. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WEO/Issues/2021/03/23/world-economic-outlook-april-2021
European Securities and Markets Authority. (2019). Advice on Initial Coin Offerings and Crypto-Assets. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/library/esma50-157-1391_crypto_advice.pdf
International Monetary Fund. (2021). Global Financial Stability Report: Preparing for the Next Wave of Uncertainty. Retrieved June 11, 2023, from https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/GFSR/Issues/2021/03/31/global-financial-stability-report-april-2021
International Monetary Fund. (2016). Fintech and Financial Services: Initial Considerations. https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/sdn/2016/sdn1605.pdf
International Monetary Fund. (2017). Virtual Currencies and Beyond: Initial Considerations. https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/Staff-Discussion-Notes/Issues/2017/06/20/Virtual-Currencies-and-Beyond-Initial-Considerations-45003
International Monetary Fund. (2018). Crypto Assets: Key Developments, Regulatory Issues, and Financial Stability. https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/Policy-Papers/Issues/2018/11/13/Crypto-Assets-Key-Developments-Regulatory-Issues-and-Financial-Stability-46232
International Monetary Fund. (2019). Report on the Treatment of Crypto Assets in Macroeconomic Statistics. https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/Policy-Papers/Issues/2019/01/15/Report-on-the-Treatment-of-Crypto-Assets-in-Macroeconomic-Statistics-46560
International Monetary Fund. (2020). Global Financial Stability Report: Markets in the Time of COVID-19. https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/GFSR/Issues/2020/09/30/october-2020-global-financial-stability-report
